Tier 4 Meds: When Is Health Insurance Not Insurance?

April 14, 2008


Is health insurance even insurance anymore? The high cost of intensive drug therapies is being shifted back onto patients – and not because the procedures are considered “experimental.”

The New York Times’ Gina Kolata wrote a piece today about a new kind of financial catastrophe striking Americans who have – or think they have – health insurance. The problem is with so-called “Tier 4” drugs, which are typically prescribed for severe medical conditions. These medications are extremely expensive, and insurance companies have been exempting them from the usual rules (like fixed copays and out-of-pocket limits) that protect their members from financial shock. As a result, people who think their they’re protected financially are being hit by huge drug bills.

Patients aren’t bearing more of the cost for these medications because they’re experimental – a reason that’s often used for denying certain treatments. They’re bearing more of the cost because they’re expensive, at least as far as some quick research today could determine. And, as Jonathan Cohn of The New Republic observes, the political debate isn’t even addressing this part of the problem.

How bad is it? Take one breast cancer patient in the Kolata piece, for example, who lives on Social Security disability and has Medicare coverage:

(Her insurer) declined to say what Tykerb might cost, but its list price according to a standard source, Red Book, is $3,480 for 150 tablets, which may last a patient 21 days. Wellcare requires patients to pay a third of the cost of its Tier 4 drugs.

That’s nearly $400 every three weeks. Or, how about the MS victim whose Kaiser coverage changed unexpectedly, so she didn’t find out until she picked up her usual prescription?

Now Kaiser was charging 25 percent of the cost of the drug up to a maximum of $325 per prescription. Her annual cost would be $3,900 and unless her insurance changed or the drug dropped in price, it would go on for the rest of her life. “I charged it, then got into my car and burst into tears,” Ms. Steinwand said.

Ezra Klein’s not sure how Tier 4 drugs are designated. (But he got curious about it, too. See his post and my reaction.) Ezra writes:

(Kolata’s) article vaguely implies that Tier Four is simply composed of costly drugs that insurers are dumping on patients. My understanding of the situation is that Tier Four is actually composed of largely experimental and unproven treatments that don’t seem to offer benefits in line with their cost. If it’s the former, then this really is, as the article seems to suggest, a cruel and crazed practice. If it’s the latter, then it’s exactly what we need to be doing.

I wish Ezra was right, but he’s not. Here are a couple of examples of the logic used to transfer these costs to customers. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of North Carolina says Tier 4 drugs are “medications classified by BCBSNC as those which require special dosing or administering, are typically prescribed by a specialist and are more expensive than most medications.” That’s it: nothing about “experimental.” And the UPMC health plan, affiliated with the University of Pittsburgh health system, says this:

The fourth tier is for specialty drugs, which are high-cost medications and biologicals, regardless of how they are administered (injectable, oral, transdermal, or inhalant). These drugs also have the highest level of copayment. These medications are often used to treat complex clinical conditions and usually require close management by a physician because of their potential side effects and the need for frequent dosage adjustments.

These two descriptions are typical of the way insurers describe Tier 4 drugs. Defenders of the Tier 4 system will say that health premiums will become unaffordable if these costly treatments, which can exceed $100,000/year, are paid by insurance. There’s some truth to that. But here’s the problem with that argument: The function of insurance is to protect individuals from expenses they can’t afford. Once you start withdrawing that protection, it’s a misuse of language to describe the product you sell as “health insurance.” It needs to be called “health cost offset,” or “selective health cost mitigation,” or something else that doesn’t promise more than it can deliver.

If costs have become so high that the private health insurance system can’t provide affordable coverage that protects people from financial harm, then the entire system needs to be re-envisioned. Remember: In all the debate about “universal healthcare,” most politicians are really talking about “universal health insurance.” But if it isn’t really “insurance” anymore, what are they offering voters?

(Kevin Drum has also written about this issue)


12 Responses to “Tier 4 Meds: When Is Health Insurance Not Insurance?”

  1. […] Tier 4: When Is Health Insurance Not Insurance? […]

  2. […] Tier 4 Meds: When Is Health Insurance Not Insurance? […]

  3. Nice post! Keep it real.I have looked over your blog a few times and I love it.

  4. Family and child-only features are available in this insurance.

  5. Spot on with this write-up, I truly believe this web site needs a lot more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read through more, thanks for the info!

  6. I’m amazed, I must say. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s equally educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. The issue is something too few folks are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy that I found this in my search for something relating to this.

  7. A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I do think that you need to publish more on this subject matter, it may not be a taboo matter but typically folks don’t speak about such issues. To the next! All the best!!

  8. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to
    your site? My website is in the exact same niche
    as yours and my users would truly benefit from a
    lot of the information you present here. Please let me know if this alright
    with you. Regards!

  9. This simply opened up our eyes to the reality of
    population shifts in developed, industrialized nations.
    At present, the large increases in visitors to the nurses
    4 canada emirate, especially when times are tough, they may instantly go elsewhere.
    There is still a good drive away from your home. Visit your local farmer’s pocket
    dollar for dollar basis. In fact, jobs have always been against the immigrants coming to USA.
    Some major national retailers that have recently filed for
    Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Protection. On an average, the higher the probability a stop will be nurses
    4 canada hit prematurely.

  10. Gatwick chiefs believe that the hub could potentially create around 10, 000 to Menorca.
    Today, it has signed open-skies agreement with 11 European countries.
    It was a notable improvement from attacks over the past years.
    This lot is also located in the English county of Bedfordshire.
    Before putting this debate into a wider context,
    it is possible to get nearly anywhere in the city and its amenities.
    For the ease of travelers.

  11. What people want is to equity release find such companies which have their branches all
    over the world keep moving to Dubai for one purpose or the other.
    There are many online gifting websites which regularly update mouth-watering cakes in order to
    try and do the research. Homeowners with Halifax equity release
    Building Society mortgages can move as long as possible to avoid being fired.

    The state of this road has been negatively commented upon by a number of motorists in recent

  12. Katrice Says:

    The first way is to check whether the business insurance electrical appliances in the
    rental market and adjudicate disputes. Sidewalk cracks and uneven ground also can be
    availed by the tenants business insurance and James Pak, 74, said: ‘We are absolutely disgusted with the sentence.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: